the word EVEN is/has been/was misused

[nelson13]

a conversation:

An American: Students there have an accent even worse than mine.

My reply: The word EVEN is/has been/was misused; your accent is good.

Which tense should I use?

Thank you very much.

 

[SoothingDave]

"Even" isn't really the word to be concerned about here.

 

[Barb_D]

Yes, the word "worse" was misused.

 

[Raymott]

Forgetting the content, if someone has just misused a word, you would say, "You've misused the word 'even'" or perhaps "The word 'even' is misused there." If it's just been spoken, there's no need for 'was' or 'has been'.

 

[nelson13]

sorry,

could you tell me in what way this sentence is wrong?
(for certain I remembered the wrong thing

 

[Raymott]

sorry,

could you tell me in what way this sentence is wrong?
(for certain I remembered the wrong thing

Which sentence? You haven't given one.

 

[nelson13]

In some previous replies some of the members of this forum said the original sentence is problematic.

 

[charliedeut]

In some previous replies some of the members of this forum said the original sentence is problematic.

My guess is that accents are not usually described as good or bad: an accent, IMO, can be strong, or weak, or nice, or what have you, but usually not good or bad.

 

[emsr2d2]

In some previous replies some of the members of this forum said the original sentence is problematic.

You seem to think that the word that has been misused is "even". It's not. The word which you want to say has been misused is "worse". If you are trying to say that the person's American accent is good, then you want to tell them that their use of the word "worse" suggests that their accent is bad. You disagree. It doesn't matter that they said "even worse". They could have said "much worse" or "a lot worse" etc. You think they should not have suggested that theirs is bad, by using the word "worse".

American: Students there have an accent even worse than mine!
You: I think you're misusing the word "worse" there. Your accent is great!

 

[Tdol]

The American speaker could have been joking or trying to make a criticism politely. I think the truth lies not in the bare words but what the speaker was trying to achieve.

 

[nelson13]

Yes, you are absolutely correct in saying so. So my question was which tense I should use in such a situation but somehow another problem in the sentence propped up.

 

[Tdol]

I'd use either the past or present perfect.