[Idiom] You can lead a horse to water but you cannot make him drink.

[Eugene01]

1. Can you say MAY instead of CAN?
2. Are there any other synonymous idioms?

 

[5jj]

1. Can you say MAY instead of CAN?

Welcome to the forum, Eugene. :hi:


We could use may, but we don't. It would lose the contrasting balance of can/can't.

 

[BobK]

:up: The other thing in favour of 'can' is that it emphasizes the idea of doing as much as you can..

Another idiom - similar in some ways (emphasizing the limits of what can be done) but not meaning the same - is 'You can take the <noun> out of <place> but you can't take <place> out of the <noun>' - which refers to the influence of the place you're born in on who you are: a non-PC example is 'You can take the girl out of Essex but you can't take Essex out of the girl'.

b

 

[MartinEnglish]

I prefer Stan Laurel's variation, "You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead."

 

[BobK]

And I prefer Gertrude Stein's -?) 'You can lead a whore to culture but you can't make her think.'

b

 

[tanitatine]

"This idiom appeared in literature over the centuries in a variety of forms;for example, in the play Narcissus, which was published in 1602, of unknown authorship, subtitled as A Twelfe Night merriment, played by youths of the parish at the College of Saint John the Baptist in Oxford:

Your parents have done what they coode,
They can but bringe horse to the water brinke,
But horse may choose whether that horse will drinke. "

​

As a EFL teacher,I can interpret this idiom by saying that we cannot force a child or put pressure on him to learn if he is not willing and ready to do it.

"People, like horses, will only do what they have a mind to do"

Happy Days!