Why are there so many rules in English grammar? Is every rule considered necessary?

Status
Not open for further replies.

english_extreme

New member
Joined
Jun 15, 2023
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Indonesian
Home Country
Indonesia
Current Location
Indonesia
Except for basic rules that I know are necessary, there are some excessive rules that have no benefits other than to complicate things for the user because a whole sentence is already self-explanatory.
For example:
I go to school.
He go to school.
He go to school yesterday.
The above 3 sentences are self-explanatory without the proper English verb 'went' and 'goes'.

One mouse, two mouse, three mouse. Instead of one mouse, two mice, three mice.

Even a native speaker also admits that there is another language that is easier than English to use.
 
Last edited:
Nobody designed or invented the language. There have always been simplified pidgins that facilitate communication and commerce.

There is, however, a vast difference in the ideas that can be expressed with a pidgin versus the actual language.
 
Last edited:
As so often happens when people make claims about the implicity of some language, the speaker in #1 exaggerates the simplicity of Indonesian. He suggests that Indonesian das only one form for verbs - much simpler than eat/ate or go/went. He fails to mention such forms as these:

  • ajar = to teach
  • ajari = to teach (imperative, locative)
  • ajarilah = to teach (jussive, locative)
  • ajarkan = to teach (imperative, causative/applicative)
  • ajarkanlah = to teach (jussive, causative/applicative)
  • ajarlah = to teach (jussive, active)
  • ajaran = teachings
  • belajar = to learn (intransitive, active)
  • diajar = to be taught (intransitive, active)
  • diajari = to be taught (transitive, locative)
  • diajarkan = to be taught (transitive, causative/applicative)
  • dipelajari = to be studied (locative)
  • dipelajarkan = to be studied (causative/applicative)
  • mempelajari = to study (locative)
  • mempelajarkan = to study (causative/applicative)
  • mengajar = to teach (intransitive, active)
  • mengajarkan = to teach (transitive, casuative/applicative)
  • mengajari = to teach (transitive, locative)
  • pelajar = student
  • pelajari = to study (imperative, locative)
  • pelajarilah = to study (jussive, locative)
  • pelajarkan = to study (imperative, causative/applicative)
  • pelajarkanlah = to study (jussive, causative/applicative)
  • pengajar = teacher, someone who teaches
  • pelajaran = subject, education
  • pelajari = to study (jussive, locative)
  • pelajarkan = to study (jussive, causative/applicative)
  • pengajaran = lesson
  • pembelajaran = learning
  • terajar = to be taught (accidentally)
  • terajari = to be taught (accidentally, locative)
  • terajarkan = to be taught (accidentally, causative/applicative)
  • terpelajar = well-educated, literally "been taught"
  • terpelajari = been taught (locative)
  • terpelajarkan = been taught (causative/applicative)
  • berpelajaran = is educated, literally "has education"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top