cubezero2
Member
- Joined
- Nov 8, 2013
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Chinese
- Home Country
- China
- Current Location
- China
Hi, everyone.
I have come across the following sentence recently.
But the article is from The Diplomat. So, I checked this with an English friend, who said it’s correct and is a rhetorical question. He was so kind and further expanded on the subject by giving me the following example:
I decided to dig into this and went to the wiki page for rhetorical questions. The first quote I found was "What have the Romans ever done for us?", rather than "What do the Romans have done for us?" I went through the wiki page and consequently opened several other webpages dedicated to this phenomenon. No example has been found to use the “do/does + subject + have + past participle” form.
I was perplexed. Now I’m utterly lost.
I’d like to hear your thoughts on this.
Many thanks
Richard
I have come across the following sentence recently.
I originally thought the writer had meant to use the present perfect tense and unfortunately made a faux pas and the sentence should be re-written as "has China planned".What does China have planned for the Type055 cruiser (or cruiser-size destroyer)?
http://thediplomat.com/2016/10/lets-talk-about-the-chinese-navys-type-055-destroyer/
But the article is from The Diplomat. So, I checked this with an English friend, who said it’s correct and is a rhetorical question. He was so kind and further expanded on the subject by giving me the following example:
I thought perhaps when people write rhetorical questions they do use this special form.A:What has Daniel planned to spend his 30000rmb on? I heard he will get a car.
B: I don't know, he said he only has 30000 rmb but he doesn't want to buy a second-hand car.
A: So, what does he have planned for his30000 rmb? This isn't enough for a new car.
I decided to dig into this and went to the wiki page for rhetorical questions. The first quote I found was "What have the Romans ever done for us?", rather than "What do the Romans have done for us?" I went through the wiki page and consequently opened several other webpages dedicated to this phenomenon. No example has been found to use the “do/does + subject + have + past participle” form.
I was perplexed. Now I’m utterly lost.
I’d like to hear your thoughts on this.
Many thanks
Richard
Last edited: