[Grammar] What did you think of Ms. lwata's presentation?

Status
Not open for further replies.

kadioguy

Key Member
Joined
Mar 4, 2017
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
Taiwan
Current Location
Taiwan
[In a question of the Toeic listening test]

Man: What did you think of Ms. lwata's presentation?

Woman: I wasn't able to attend.

----
1. Why does he use "did" rather than "do"? In what context do native speakers use "What did you think of"? I always use "what do you think?" in the forum. :-?

2. Is the green part OK? Or is there a better way to say it?
----
[Source]
yCUu1ij.jpg
 
Man: What did you think of Ms. lwata's presentation?

----
1. Why does he use "did" rather than "do"?
Because he is asking 'you' about their thoughts at or just after the past time of the presentation.
 
Because he is asking 'you' about their thoughts at or just after the past time of the presentation.

So, (my original conversation)

[The concert has just ended]

A: What did you think of the concert?
B: It was great!
---
C: What do you think of the concert?
D: It is great!

====

The conversation between [A and B] is correct, right?
 
So, (my original conversation)

[The concert has just ended]

A: What did you think of the concert?
B: It was great!
---
C: What do you think of the concert?
D: It is great!
====

The conversation between [A and B] is correct, right?
Yes. The concert is in the past, so you need the past simple.
 
What do you think of the concert?
It is great.

That dialogue could take place only during the concert.
 
Yes. The concert is in the past, so you need the past simple.

The concert may be in the past but the opinion of the concert could be formed or re-formed in the present, couldn't it?
 
It's unlikely.
 
The concert may be in the past but the opinion of the concert could be formed or re-formed in the present, couldn't it?
In some circumstances, yes. For example, if I'd been a performer or organizer. In that case, you'd ask How do you think the concert went?
 
I think one's opinions are not always static; at least mine aren't.
 
I think one's opinions are not always static; at least mine aren't.
OK, so your answer may be different, but the question will be the same.
 
And there is a grey area with do/did you think of something. I think you may be looking for an absolute certainty that may not be there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top