S+"froze/beV+frozen/beV+freezing"+"to death"-Hundreds of people froze in the water.

Status
Not open for further replies.

z7655431

Member
Joined
Jan 12, 2016
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
Taiwan
Current Location
Taiwan
S+"froze/beV+frozen/beV+freezing"+"to death"-Hundreds of people froze in the water.

A.
By the time the rescue team got to the scene, the ship had sunk to the ground of the ocean and hundreds of people had been frozen in ice-cold water.

(1)Is this sentence correct?
(2)In the red part, should I delete the word been?
(3)In the orange part, should I add an "the" before "ice-cold water"?

B.
Besides, the following are some related questions:
a. Hundreds of people froze in the ice-cold water.
b. Hundreds of people were frozen in the ice-cold water.
c. John froze to death.
d. John was freezing to death.
e. John was frozen to death.
Are these sentences all correct? What's difference between these sentences? Which expression is more common?
 
Re: S+"froze/beV+frozen/beV+freezing"+"to death"-Hundreds of people froze in the wate

Where did you find this? '...to the ground of the ocean' is not a natural English sentence.
 
Re: S+"froze/beV+frozen/beV+freezing"+"to death"-Hundreds of people froze in the wate

Where did you find this? '...to the ground of the ocean' is not a natural English sentence.
By the time the rescue team got to the scene, the ship had sunk to the ground of the ocean and hundreds of people had been frozen in ice-cold water.
-This sentence is from my teacher's handout. I don't know whether my teacher wrote it by herself or not, or just copied it from other sources. I myself think that the "ground" should be the "bottom". Right?

The other sentences from a to e are written by myself. And I am wondering if they're OK and if there's any difference between them.
 
Re: S+"froze/beV+frozen/beV+freezing"+"to death"-Hundreds of people froze in the wate

Please define "OK" in your question above. Do you mean "grammatically correct" or "semantically sound"? The last sentence (B.e.), for example, may be interpreted as "Somebody killed John by freezing him." As to the other part of your question- yes, each sentence has a different meaning.
 
Last edited:
Re: S+"froze/beV+frozen/beV+freezing"+"to death"-Hundreds of people froze in the wate

Please define "OK" in your question above. Do you mean "grammatically correct" or "semantically sound"? The last sentence (B.e.), for example, may be interpreted as "Somebody killed John by freezing him." As to the other part of your question- yes, each sentence has a different meaning.
The OK means English native speakers can accept and won't feel weird about the sentences I gave.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top