[Grammar] Questions about comma placement and "lie vs lay"

Status
Not open for further replies.

writekdjones

New member
Joined
Aug 18, 2012
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
Hello! I'm an author who has been working on brushing up my grammar by practicing line-edits on my own manuscript. However, there are some spots I'm not quite sure about...

1. (Comma placement) She kept her gaze at her feet, not wanting to look at the approaching dais before her (comma?) or at the great black throne that crowned the room.
I know you're only supposed to use a comma if there are two independent clauses (or so I think). I wasn't sure if "black throne" and "crowned" were the subject and verb, or if "she" at the very beginning is still the main subject.

2. (Lie vs. lay)
Her blood chilled at the memory of what lay beyond those doors...
The pieces of the mirror’s shattered surface lay on the filthy floor below...

Did I get it right? If I didn't, could you please explain why so I'll know better next time? Lie vs. lay is terribly confusing to me.

Thank you so much for taking a look at my thread!
 
Her blood chilled at the memory of what lay beyond those doors...
The pieces of the mirror’s shattered surface lay on the filthy floor below...

Did I get it right? If I didn't, could you please explain why so I'll know better next time? Lie vs. lay is terribly confusing to me.
Welcome to the forum, writekdjones. :hi:

Your two sentences are correct.

lay/laid laid - put (somebody/something) in a position.

lie/lay/lain - be in a position.
 
Welcome from me, too.:-D
1. (Comma placement) She kept her gaze at her feet, not wanting to look at the approaching dais before her (comma?) or at the great black throne that crowned the room.
I know you're only supposed to use a comma if there are two independent clauses (or so I think). I wasn't sure if "black throne" and "crowned" were the subject and verb, or if "she" at the very beginning is still the main subject.



No comma is necessary in my opinion, but you will often see one in places like that, where it is helpful in breaking up a long sentence and aiding understanding.

You will observe that we prefer to receive unrelated questions in separate threads.

Rover
 
You will observe that we prefer to receive unrelated questions in separate threads.

Rover

Thanks for answering my question, Rover, and for letting me know. I'll do so next time. =)

As for your answer, that's what confuses me. It seems some punctuation is optional, or at least, you have choices. (Not always, but sometimes.)

Thanks for the welcome. :)
 
Welcome to the forum, writekdjones. :hi:


lay/laid laid - put (somebody/something) in a position.

lie/lay/lain - be in a position.

Thank you, 5jj, for the welcome, as well as answering my question. I appreciate it. =)

Your examples make sense for me. I always tend to "muddy up" lie/lay in my head, so thank you for simplifying their uses and meanings for me!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top