literature vs literatures

Status
Not open for further replies.

ostap77

Key Member
Joined
Sep 9, 2010
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Ukrainian
Home Country
Ukraine
Current Location
Ukraine
What's the difference between the singular and the plural? When do we use each of them?
 
Last edited:
What's the difference between the singular and the olural? When do we use each of them?
We don't use "literatures". "Literature" is an uncountable mass noun.
 
We don't use "literatures". "Literature" is an uncountable mass noun.

We don't ? "Literatures of Modernity"-Ryerson University in Toronto. It even offers the MA degree in Literatures of Modernity.
 
What's the difference between the singular and the plural? When do we use each of them?


*** NOT A TEACHER ***

(1) I most respectfully and gently submit that here in the United States, the plural is used.

(2) Among the many examples I googled:

(a) We study and teach the languages, literatures, and cultures of the Russian and

other Slavic peoples. (University of California at Berkeley)

(b) The only journal in the United States that focuses exclusively on American

Indian literatures. [My note: There are many Native-American tribes, each with its own

particular literature.]

(c) The Department of East Asian Languages and literatures at the University of

Hawaii. [My note: Chinese literature, Japanese literature, Korean literature, etc.]
 
*** NOT A TEACHER ***

(1) I most respectfully and gently submit that here in the United States, the plural is used.

(2) Among the many examples I googled:

(a) We study and teach the languages, literatures, and cultures of the Russian and

other Slavic peoples. (University of California at Berkeley)

(b) The only journal in the United States that focuses exclusively on American

Indian literatures. [My note: There are many Native-American tribes, each with its own

particular literature.]

(c) The Department of East Asian Languages and literatures at the University of

Hawaii. [My note: Chinese literature, Japanese literature, Korean literature, etc.]

When I say "Ukrainian Literature" I'd be conveying generic meaning. If I choose to use "Ukrainian Literatures" I'd be refering to either different authors or different times when they were written?
 
When I say "Ukrainian Literature" I'd be conveying generic meaning. If I choose to use "Ukrainian Literatures" I'd be refering to either different authors or different times when they were written?


I do not know.

Hopefully, someone will soon give us the answer to your excellent question.
 
'Literatures' is pretty uncommon in both varieties of English, BNC has 49 citations (5,246 for the uncountable) and COCA has 305 (28,055 for the uncountable). I cannot come up with a natural context for 'Ukranian literatures', though doubtless somebody will.

As far as learners are concerned, I would tell anyone who came up with an example of the word in the plural that if they use word as an uncountable noun, they will be correct in 99.9% of the sentences they create. If they use it in the plural form they are likely to sound unnatural in 99% of the sentences they create.
 
You won't need to use "literatures" unless you need to write in the language of academic postmodernism.
“Literatures” has been introduced into discourse to deconstruct the hegemonic concept of “Literature” which implies that there is a canonical Literature on one hand, and non-literature on the other, rather than a spectrum of this-literature and that-literature. That is, it refuses to marginalise the other-literatures. It forces us to accept the diversity or, better put, the diversities existant in that which we call the Literary. It opens a foramen into a discourse on our own private literatures; the oral, the written, perhaps even only the felt, the subtly nuanced, the barely articulated, perhaps even the pre-thought, unconscious narrative that until now has been silenced by the deafening, yet ultimately impotent, authority of a monolithic “Literature”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top