[Grammar] inverted form

Status
Not open for further replies.

atabitaraf

Key Member
Joined
May 19, 2010
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Persian
Home Country
Iran
Current Location
Iran
This statement of congratulation really made me think: May happy times and warm memories brighten your new year.
As I can see this statement has an inverted form: May + subject, although it is not a question.
I knew it that inverted forms are used in 1. questions, 2. statement of surprise or shock, 3. statements which start with semi-/negative adverbs like never, seldom, only, ... But I didn't know it can be used in statements of wishes or congratulations.
Can I use inverted forms in statements for wishes?
Thanks,
 
There is no inversion. "May" is used here as a modal verb expressing a wish.
 
There is no inversion. "May" is used here as a modal verb expressing a wish.
1. May happy times and warm memories brighten your new year.
2. H
appy times and warm memories may brighten your new year.

Sentence 1 does not start with a subject: May + subject so I just thought it must be the inverted form of sentence 2.

 
The word 'may' has different meanings in the two sentences.
[FONT=arial, sans-serif]'May' in #1 expresses a wish or hope. Another example : May you be blessed. [/FONT]
'May' in #2 expresses a possibility.

not a teacher
 
So in this case, I believe, in #1, 'may' must be an adverb and not a modal verb. Am I right?
 
'May' is a modal verb rather than an adverb.

Not a teacher.
 
'May' is a modal verb rather than an adverb.

Not a teacher.

Thanks for you beautiful answers, I think now, if 'may' is a modal verb, so #1 must be in the inverted form.
I think in wish expressions with 'may,' the inverted form is used. And so in this case, 'may' can remain a modal verb.
 
It seems that you paid no attention to the answer below. Not a teacher.
No, I did observe all the posts. But the point is that I can see a contradiction in here with the grammar I learned.
You see: If 'may' is a modal, so just in the inverted form it can be used at the beginning of our sentence. Am I right in my definition of inverted form?
My definition of inverted form:
1. In sentences with auxiliary verbs or a 'to be' verb: the place of subject with the first auxiliary verb must be exchanged.
2. In sentences without auxiliary verbs or a 'to be' verb: Do/Does/Did comes in front of the sentence.
If you agree with my statement so either #1 is inverted OR 'may' cannot be a modal. Thanks,
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top