[General] If you hadn't lied to me

Status
Not open for further replies.

Anil Giria

Member
Joined
Nov 9, 2014
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Hindi
Home Country
India
Current Location
India
If you hadn't lied to me before, I would have believed you.

I understand have is used as an infinitive (main verb)in this sentence and not as a auxiliary verb. Am I correct. (I understand infinitive is the base case of the verb)
 
"Have" is an auxiliary verb there. The entire verb is "would have believed".
 
I consider the use of "main" verb to be useful. Changing its name to something else changes nothing. This is more terminology. What is the OP to do when he/she comes across "main verb" in a different place?
 
Forget the idea of 'main verb''; it's not always helpful. The full/lexical verb in a verb phrase is the one that cariies the meaning of the event or state. If there is only one verb, that verb is the lexical verb:

Mary and Frank have been injured.- Is it present perfect tense?
We have had a lot of problems with our freezer.- Which tense is this?

I understand that full verb/lexical verb is as good as main verb?

 
"Have" is an auxiliary verb there. The entire verb is "would have believed".

I understand, "I would have believed you" is modal perfect and in modal perfect "Have" is infinitive. Am I right?

All modal perfect auxiliary verbs refer to the past.
FORM: Modal + Have (Infinitive) + Past Participle
 
"Have" is the base form (infinitive form) of the verb. It is not what we typically refer to as an infinitive. I know this terminology can be difficult and tedious.
 
"Have" is the base form (infinitive form) of the verb. It is not what we typically refer to as an infinitive. I know this terminology can be difficult and tedious.

May I say that when we say " have" is the base case of the verb, we can't classify it into auxiliary verb. For eg: I have gone there. Here "have" is an auxiliary verb and not the main verb/base case of the verb. Am I right?
 
Yes you are, but "have" is still the base form of the verb.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top