astepforward
Junior Member
- Joined
- Jun 29, 2018
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Polish
- Home Country
- Poland
- Current Location
- Poland
Hello!
Is the 2) version of John's responses the only applicable option from these two below? Is it due to the fact that John's mum knows the time of the car repair (it can be considered as a specific time) and we use the simple past in such cases even if it is a kind of retrospective-explanatory utterance which begs for the perfect aspect?
Mum: John, mow the lawn before you leave!
1) John: I have helped you with the car repair, go and ask Max to do it
2) John: I helped you with the car repair, go and ask Max to do it
Is the 2) version of John's responses the only applicable option from these two below? Is it due to the fact that John's mum knows the time of the car repair (it can be considered as a specific time) and we use the simple past in such cases even if it is a kind of retrospective-explanatory utterance which begs for the perfect aspect?
Mum: John, mow the lawn before you leave!
1) John: I have helped you with the car repair, go and ask Max to do it
2) John: I helped you with the car repair, go and ask Max to do it