Europeans celebrate their birthdays regardless of age, but for Asians, birthday celebrations are only for children.

[teacherjapan]

Is this a correct sentence?

Europeans celebrate their birthdays regardless of age, but for Asians, birthday celebrations are only for children.

 

[emsr2d2]

Is this a correct sentence correct?

Europeans celebrate their birthdays regardless of age no comma here but, for Asians, birthday celebrations are only for children.

Please note my changes above.

 

[teacherjapan]

Is it considered wrong to put a comma before “but”?

What about the case when you use “while”? Would you put a comma before that?

Europeans celebrate their birthdays regardless of age (,) while for Asians, birthday celebrations are only for children.

 

[Tarheel]

Europeans celebrate their birthdays regardless of age, but for Asians, birthday celebrations are only for children.

Remove the comma after "Asians" and it's perfect.

 

[Rover_KE]

Europeans celebrate their birthdays regardless of age, but for Asians, birthday celebrations are only for children.

Is that statement true for all the billions of people in the 48 countries of Asia?