Nightmare85
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2009
- Member Type
- Interested in Language
- Native Language
- German
- Home Country
- Germany
- Current Location
- Germany
Hello,
This could become a little bit complex now.
Okay, we know their meanings:
"I must not do it." - I just can't do it because it would destroy my health (Example: Hard drugs.)
"I don't have to do it." - My parents have forbidden me to do this (example: Inviting friends when they are not at home)
(I'm not 100% sure if "I have not to do it" is okay!)
"I need not do it." Instead of writing 2+2+2 I just can write 6; the first one is unnecessary.
So, now the problem:
In several movies I heard similar conversations like:
"May I have some drinks, please?"
"Of course you can! You don't have to ask!"
This confuses me!
Why isn't it: "You need not ask, just take some drinks!"
(I learned in these forums that it's okay to write "You need not ask" instead of "You need not to ask".)
Is this an American English vs. British English topic?
Cheers!
This could become a little bit complex now.
Okay, we know their meanings:
"I must not do it." - I just can't do it because it would destroy my health (Example: Hard drugs.)
"I don't have to do it." - My parents have forbidden me to do this (example: Inviting friends when they are not at home)
(I'm not 100% sure if "I have not to do it" is okay!)
"I need not do it." Instead of writing 2+2+2 I just can write 6; the first one is unnecessary.
So, now the problem:
In several movies I heard similar conversations like:
"May I have some drinks, please?"
"Of course you can! You don't have to ask!"
This confuses me!
Why isn't it: "You need not ask, just take some drinks!"
(I learned in these forums that it's okay to write "You need not ask" instead of "You need not to ask".)
Is this an American English vs. British English topic?
Cheers!