misu
Junior Member
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2020
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- German
- Home Country
- Germany
- Current Location
- Japan
"can" & "be able to" do not always share the same meaning, do they?
Hello everyone![Smile :) :)]()
We use can to say that something is possible or allowed, or that somebody has the ability to do something.
Let me use three examples, one for each case:
1 I can come to your party on Friday.
2 You can park here.
3 I can play the guitar.
But as we all know, can has has only two forms: can (presente tense) and could (past tense). So sometimes it is necessary to use be able to.
If we use be able to for the above three examples wanting to express the meaings of possible, allowed and ability to do something, it appers to me that be able to does not cover all three meanings as can:
1 I will be able to come to your party on Friday. (OK: able to conveys the meaning of "possibility")
2. You will be able to park here. (This appers to me not to convey the meaining of "being allowed to")
3. I will be able to play the guitar (Ok: able to, of course, conveys the meaning of "being able to do something")
Therefore, I think that in sentence 2 be able to doesn't work well. It should be rather written as follows:
You will be allowed to park here.
What is your opinion on this?
Thanks in advance
Hello everyone
We use can to say that something is possible or allowed, or that somebody has the ability to do something.
Let me use three examples, one for each case:
1 I can come to your party on Friday.
2 You can park here.
3 I can play the guitar.
But as we all know, can has has only two forms: can (presente tense) and could (past tense). So sometimes it is necessary to use be able to.
If we use be able to for the above three examples wanting to express the meaings of possible, allowed and ability to do something, it appers to me that be able to does not cover all three meanings as can:
1 I will be able to come to your party on Friday. (OK: able to conveys the meaning of "possibility")
2. You will be able to park here. (This appers to me not to convey the meaining of "being allowed to")
3. I will be able to play the guitar (Ok: able to, of course, conveys the meaning of "being able to do something")
Therefore, I think that in sentence 2 be able to doesn't work well. It should be rather written as follows:
You will be allowed to park here.
What is your opinion on this?
Thanks in advance