greegorush
Member
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2009
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Russian
- Home Country
- Russian Federation
- Current Location
- Russian Federation
Hello!
I have some doubts so I hope you help me dispel them.
The rule: You can use as when two things happen at the same time.
Examples: We all waved goodbye to Liz as she drove away.
I watched her as she opened the letter.
Can you turn off the light as you go out?
Kate slipped as she was getting off the bus.
We met Paul as we were leaving the hotel.
As I understood we can use the -ing clauses in the last three sentences without changing the meaning:
Can you turn off the light going out?
Kate slipped getting off the bus.
We met Paul leaving the hotel (not sure)
The conclusion: we can use the -ing clause instead of as when the subject and the object are the same.
Exception: the see somebody do/doing rule (limited verbs can be used such as see, hear, feel, notice, listen, find...)
I'd be grateful if you could help me make it clear.
Thank you in advance!
I have some doubts so I hope you help me dispel them.
The rule: You can use as when two things happen at the same time.
Examples: We all waved goodbye to Liz as she drove away.
I watched her as she opened the letter.
Can you turn off the light as you go out?
Kate slipped as she was getting off the bus.
We met Paul as we were leaving the hotel.
As I understood we can use the -ing clauses in the last three sentences without changing the meaning:
Can you turn off the light going out?
Kate slipped getting off the bus.
We met Paul leaving the hotel (not sure)
The conclusion: we can use the -ing clause instead of as when the subject and the object are the same.
Exception: the see somebody do/doing rule (limited verbs can be used such as see, hear, feel, notice, listen, find...)
I'd be grateful if you could help me make it clear.
Thank you in advance!
Last edited: