[Grammar] Amy who was punished for talking in class received a detention form.

[sitifan]

Amy who was punished for talking in class received a detention form.

= Amy being punished for talking in class received a detention form.

= Amy punished for talking in class received a detention form.

https://twenglishstudy1.pixnet.net/blog/post/355703894

Are the above sentences acceptable to native speakers?

 

[5jj]

Amy who was punished for talking in class received a detention form.
= Amy being punished for talking in class received a detention form.
= Amy punished for talking in class received a detention form.

None of those three is correct.

 

[Rover_KE]

I could not find them in your link because I would have had to accept cookies. I am not prepared to do that.