[Grammar] Sentences with the participle

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kotfor

Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2011
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Ukrainian
Home Country
Belarus
Current Location
Ukraine
1)Being occupied with the work, I didn’t get time to talk to her.

Is being necessary?

Occupied with the work, I didn’t get time to talk to her.

2) It being a small cot, he couldn’t sleep on it.

Is it OK to rephrase this sentence in the following way

Having a small cot, he couldn’t sleep on it.

3) The dog having bitten the postman, the farmer decided to shoot it.

Is it the "nominative absolute construction". If yes, would the following sentence be correct?

The dog bite the postman, the farmer decided to shoot it.

4) Being a child he didn't like to study. /Is this sentence wrong? Should it be: "When he was a child he didn't like to study." ?
 
Last edited:
1)Being occupied with the work, I didn’t get time to talk to her.

Is being necessary?

Occupied with [the] work, I didn’t get time to talk to her. That's OK.


2)
It being a small cot, he couldn’t sleep on it.

Is it OK to rephrase this sentence in the following way

Having a small cot, he couldn’t sleep on it.

The sentence starting "Having" does not mean the same as the first sentence, so you can't really call it rephrasing.

3) The dog having bitten the postman, the farmer decided to shoot it.
This sentence is totally incorrect. There are a couple of possibilities:
- The dog, having bitten the postman, had to be shot by the farmer.
- Having bitten the postman, the dog had to be shot by the farmer.

- Having bitten the postman, the farmer decided to shoot the dog. (Note, potentially ambiguous, as it could mean that the farmer had bitten the postman!)

Is it the "nominative absolute construction"? If yes, would the following sentence be correct?

The dog [STRIKE]bite[/STRIKE] bit the postman, the farmer decided to shoot it.

emsr2d2
 
2) What is the difference between them?

3) I borrowed this sentence from here Forms of the Participle
As far as I understand they consider it correct, somehow.

4) Being a child he didn't like to study. /Is this sentence wrong? Should it be: "When he was a child he didn't like to study." ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ask a Teacher

If you have a question about the English language and would like to ask one of our many English teachers and language experts, please click the button below to let us know:

(Requires Registration)
Back
Top